Leaderboard
728x15
Showing posts with label Healthcare Reform. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Healthcare Reform. Show all posts

The Perils of Government Involvement in Health Care

A Disease Management Care Blog spawn is implacably opposed to a Romney Presidency.  The argument is that while there's admiration for Mitt's successes as a businessman, running a government is better left to accountable politicians.

Which the DMCB appreciates. That doesn't mean there isn't a downside to the meddling of Republicans as well as Democrats.  Take health care for example.

Turbocharged by decades of direct government funding and favorable tax policies, insatiable healthcare consumer demand has created a medical-industrial bubble that is eating close to 20% of the U.S. economy.  Since Washington DC's direct costs are outstripping tax receipts, the same political process that got us into trouble is now supposed to get us out.  While the President's proposed 2015 budget has some painful cuts, that's nothing compared to the looming havoc being threatened by the coming fiscal cliff.  This is government accountability?

For a smaller example of the dysfunction created by government meddling, consider the electronic health record (EHR) mess.  Despite warnings from the DMCB that EHRs' documentation capabilities enable increased billings for the same care, both Presidents Bush and Obama promoted the EHR as an informatics cost-reducing panacea. 

It turns out the DMCB was right. This OIG report raised the possibility that EHRs are behind a recent coding uptick, which was further examined in this telling New York Times article by Reed Abelson et al. 

Government response? This threatening warning to stop using a product as designed that our political class had promoted all along.

(Latest update: Reversing course on years of being conspicuously silent in the face of the Adminstration's health reform bullying, the hospitals are pushing back.   Nothing like the threat of budget cuts to clarify just who your allies are - and aren't.  The cliff promises to be an interesting ride.)

Looking Ahead to the Second Enrollment Wave of Obamacare This Fall

Big or small?
The latest just-published edition of Health Affairs has a sobering reminder written by Tricia Brooks ("Open Enrollment, Take Two") that the healthcare marketplace wars will recommence on November 15.

That's when open enrollment starts all over again. While the good news is that more than 7 million people got health insurance through the on-line marketplaces, the bad news is that there are now 7 million people who will have to use the process again to get their insurance renewed.

While Dr. Brooks is generally upbeat and hopes our politicians will put their constituents first, the Population Health Blog asks.... what could possibly go wrong?

What the PHB learned.....

Development work isn't finished yet.  The back-room and behind-the-scenes web machinery dealing with application questions, required consumer notifications and eligibility issues are continuing to get tweaked. In addition, the Feds are working to upgrade the electronic and other processes that are necessary to verify identity and immigration status. Plus, it has yet to be fully integrated with the commercial marketplaces, Medicaid and the CHIP agencies.

It is also possible that during the renewal process, persons who underestimated their income in the process of applying for tax credits may be subject to claw back, and the individual mandate's tax penalty will rear its ugly head.  We don't know how consumers will react.

It also remains to be seen how many consumers will understand the financial assistance or miss the deadline. Look to the Administration launch reprise of a marketing campaign that encourages "tell your friends and family" word-of-mouth.

And then there is no guarantee that many states will want to - or be able to - fully cooperate.

What went unmentioned is the "wild card" of the fall political campaign.  All of the members of the House of Representatives, a third of the Senate and many Governors will be spinning Obamacare.  Thanks to the fog of political war played out our TV screens, individuals may be entering the open enrollment period with a whole new set of opinions and apprehensions.

Stay tuned!

The U.S. Health Care Debate in Five Bullet Points

"This message will self-destruct...."
The international arm of the Disease Management Care Blog is working on a presentation for the upcoming Hauptstadtkongreß in Berlin Germany.  Its "Mission Impossible" is to explain the U.S. health care system to a group of German hospital executives in a half hour.

This, in a Nußschale, is what the DMCB intends to say, using approximately eighteen PowerPoint slides:

1. While rising health care costs, as a percentage of U.S. GDP, has always been a problem, rising health care costs as a percentage of U.S. debt is widely viewed as a highly significant threat. We mean it this time.

2. The conservative vs. liberal debate over how to reduce health care costs for the U.S. government is ultimately about transferring its insurance risk.  The conservatives want to transfer risk to patients in the form of vouchers, while the liberals want to transfer risk to providers in the form of bundled payments and gain-sharing.  The liberals, so far, are handily winning the debate.

3. Risk is only half the health reform story.  The other half is quality. There is bipartisan consensus that a) U.S. health care quality could be better, and b) greater quality will mitigate insurance risk, resulting in fewer medical complications, emergency room visits and readmissions.
   
4. There is additional bipartisan consensus that a) insurance risk can be managed and b) quality can be increased when care is provided in large vertically integrated and regional provider systems.

5. If the twin exigencies of risk and quality are not addressed in the next 3-5 years, disappointment could lead to the unraveling of Obamacare and the introduction of a public payer option.

Image from Wikipedia
Leaderboard