Leaderboard
728x15
Showing posts with label Medical Home Summit. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Medical Home Summit. Show all posts

A Generic Keyword "Pitch" to Better Sell the Medical Home

Applause!
While the just concluded 2015 Medical Home Summit was a wonderful learning and networking confab, it did have it's moments of jargon-laced salesmanship.

Think mixing two parts suspect data with one part dubious claims and a helping of preordained conclusions, bake with PowerPoint and serve to a fawning audience with a garnish of sweeping generalizations. And the dessert?  Applause.

Naturally, some of the Population Health Blog's evidence-based colleagues fussed over the occasional spills of snake oil. The PHB isn't at all concerned, because it was taught years ago by the old disease management industry that even the most pristine research in the most elite journals gets spun.

And let's face it: we collectively crossed that Rubicon when the Mr. Obama sold us a health insurance reform program that promised we could keep our doctors.

Since we all gotta make a living, the PHB is pleased to offer a free service to its more honest, non-for-profit and spin-challenged colleagues. It has combined its trove of disease management nostrums with a list of medical home keywords (underlined) that appeared in many of the Summit's presentations and huckstered over cheese and wine during the Exhibit Hall receptions:

Our (insert name of your medical home program) is a transformative and population-based initiative that shifts health care delivery from volume to value that proves that that JAMA article (link here) was wrong. Our transparency is only matched by our EHR registry and teaming of physicians, nurse practitioners, social workers, office staff, clerks, temps and janitorial service workers and we (pick one: have been, will be or should be) the subject of a (pick one: grant or report) by (pick one or more: PCPCC, the Commonwealth Fund, AHRQ, Medical Home News) that further shows why JAMA was woefully mistaken.

By proactively focusing on impactful care coordination and reducing care gaps, engagement of both patients and primary care providers drives triple-aim outcomes that include (insert percent numbers here without p values), which further demonstrates the JAMA article is a despicable outlier.

Our savings, enhanced clinical outcomes, decreases in readmissions, improved patient care experience and betterment of the community show that (name of medical home program) is foundational to the success of accountable care, which is why JAMA sucks.

As a result, we conclude that (pick one or more: politicians, employers) (pick one: wisely have or definitely should) require commercial and government insurers to pay (pick one or more: millions, specialists less, or through the nose) to save primary care despite what JAMA says.

Noise to Signal Ratio in the Assessment of the Medical Home

From time to time, the Population Health Blog's consulting business generates supplemental income.  When that happens, it gets dropped into the PHB's cash flow and life goes on.

Months later, is the PHB household better off?  On one hand, every little bit helps.  On the other, total income is the result of many jobs and total well-being is only partially a function of the PHB's bank account.  In other words, it's difficult to gauge the one time contribution of a consulting gig to the "outcome" of total income.

It's a classic "noise" (total income) to "signal" (the gig) conundrum.

That's how the PHB addressed the problem of this disappointing JAMA article in its conversations with colleagues at today's Medical Home Summit meeting.  As readers will recall, this JAMA research showed no statistically significant impact on claims expense for all patients who were attributed to a medical home clinic compared to a parallel population of patients attributed to non-medical home clinics.
 
To the PHB, "total claims expense" is akin to total income, while the impact on a smaller subpopulation segment of patients with chronic conditions who were at special risk is the "gig."  Because of the overwhelming "noise" of insurance claims involving tens of thousands of patients, it's practically impossible to discern the benefit of the medical home for the smaller number of vulnerable patients.

The lesson?  While all patients assigned to a medical home clinic won't benefit, some could.  Until we understand that, we won't really know the return on investment of this approach to care. 

A Reprise of the Infamous CBO Report on Disease Management and the De-linking of Health Insurance and Wellness

Two things "heard on the street" at today's Medical Home Summit:

1) The recent JAMA article on the failure of the medical home to reduce health costs is provoking the same defensiveness as the infamous 2004 CBO report on "disease management."  PCMH advocates are using the same arguments that were used by the old DM vendors to defend their business model back in 2004.

Two of the more common ones heard by the Population Health Blog are that 1) today's model is far improved over the Ver. 1.0 reported in the JAMA article and 2) the improved health status of populations is not correlated with reduced insurance claims expense.
 
2) The bad news is that employers have given up on health insurance and many are prepared to push their workforce into the health insurance exchanges.  The good news is that they are continuing to invest in wellness and health promotion programs for their employees - not because they believe it saves money, but because it increases productivity.

In other words, commercial health insurance and wellness are being de-linked.
Leaderboard