Leaderboard
728x15
Showing posts with label handhelds. Show all posts
Showing posts with label handhelds. Show all posts

More on Health Apps: Opportunities, Risks and the Implications for Population Health Management

It's called "mHealth" but others may call it "health apps." The FDA calls it a target rich regulatory opportunity. Others may call it hype.

The Disease Management Care Blog calls it inevitable.

Writing in JAMA, Drs. Steinhubl, Muse and Topol of Scripps agree and say that the future is bright for mHealth. Its adoption is being driven by the threefold convergence of:

1) the search for solutions that address otherwise unaffordable levels of healthcare spending,

2) the availability of broadband wireless connectivity, and

3) consumer demand for individualized care.

The DMCB suspects any one of the DMCB's 5000 regular readers could have written this article. Like Steinhubl et al, they already know that patients want self-diagnosis and condition monitoring. Health consumers want greater efficiencies and enhanced patient-physician collaboration.

Even tech-skeptics have to admit that it's possible that mHealth could lead to a utilization trifecta of fewer office visits, avoided emergency room visits and decreased hospitalizations. Imagine the handheld that can accurately catalog signs and symptoms that help the user discern between a simple self-limited cold vs. a more serious case of pneumonia, or benign skipped heart beats vs. a more worrisome arrythmia.

Handheld apps for chronic conditions are more available than realized. They are on the cusp of going mainstream with assisting hypertensives, diabetics and asthmatics monitor and act on their blood pressure, insulin dosing and inhalants.

If they work right, providers could review summary data and offer guidance via emails and texts in lieu of adding a patient on to the schedule at 5 PM. If done right, the background algorithms could liberate physicians to pay greater attention to the important stuff that requires their complex cognitive or procedural skills.

The authors point out that that doesn't mean it's going to be easy. Medicine is complex and getting paid for it is more so. There's also worry - warranted or not - about the decline of face-to-face doctor-patient relationship. mHealth can lead to overwhelming data gluts characterized by a lot of numbers with little actionable insight. Finally, there's the danger that an app can offer ineffective, inaccurate or dangerous guidance that leads to patient harm.

Bravo to the editors of JAMA for recognizing the importance of the topic and committing precious space to this manuscript.

That being said, however, this article fails to give a full accounting of all the opportunities as well as risks for "mHealth."

First off, as this Kaiser Health News article demonstrates, there are two additional opportunity dimensions that draw on the population health management business model:

1) Apps are not just for diagnosis and monitoring, but also for wellness, and

2) They're being principally sponsored by commercial health insurers who not only readily embrace innovation, but probably consider apps a "sticky" way to maintain customer loyalty. That is doubly true for engaged enrollees who ultimately represent a better insurance risk.  In fact, the DMCB suspects that value proposition is so compelling that insurers are willing to use apps as a "loss leader."

Oh, and while mHealth can be built, it's far more likely it's being bought. As in population health management vendors.

Risks?  You bet.....

1) The fit of mHealth with the electronic health record (EHR) remains an open question.  The DMCB is no coding geek, but it's safe to say that it's not automatic that two independently contrived technologies can automatically "speak" to each other or that the data from an app can by downloaded, summarized and coherently presented to a user at the point of care.

2)  As noted in this article on telemonitoring, it's also not necessarily true that mHealth can be equated with stand-alone technology. Depending on the condition and the need, mHealth will have to be often tethered to human support services.

3) As even casual observers are aware, allegations of "malpractice" are not unusual in health care.  Rather than comment on its friends who make a living off of contingency fees, the DMCB will only point out that mHealth may offer a target-rich rich environment for personal injury attorneys intent on using the legal theory of joint and several liability to maximum effect.  That threat may slow adoption of mHealth.

Image from Wikipedia

CMS and Health Reform: More of the Same

Unmentioned.....
Whoa, with breathless media coverage like this (dramatically change! ambitious!) you'd think that the Feds had just announced something important about health reform. 

After reading the CMS press release, a CMS blog post and this article in the New England Journal, the Population Health Blog has concluded that it's more of the same. 

As the PHB understands it, Medicare's January 26 announcement is that it will build on three ongoing reforms:

1. Financial incentives to expand "alternative payment" methodologies to 30% of all reimbursement by 2016 and to 50% by 2018.  These include accountable care organization arrangements, monthly fees to Patient Centered Medical Homes and use of bundled payments.  In addition, 85% of fee-for-service payments that are still in place will be linked to quality by 2015, with an increase to 90% by 2018.

2. Promoting "provider integration." That apparently means a new forum called the Transforming Clinical Practice Initiative, with a first yet-to-be-planned meeting in March of 2015.  In addition, CMS will continue to rely on its Partnership for Patients and the Patient Centered Outcomes Research Institute.

3. Information technology (IT) including more promotion of electronic records, meaningful use, interoperability and universal information technology standards.

[Yawn]

The cynical PHB is not impressed. The Obama Administration was using, is using and will continue to use faux announcements to advance its reforms.  What's more, when it reads the CMS pabulum, it's riddled with the same top-down mainframe rhetoric on realigning care, moving from volume to value, accountability, alternative payment models, serving populations, building a better system, increasing coordination, convening meetings, promoting information technology etc. There are no new details here.

The PHB will share three insights, however:

1. CMS, Ms. Burwell and their White House handlers lost an opportunity to reach out to the Republicans about the sustainable growth rate and leveraging that to build on multiple areas of agreement to jumpstart bipartisan reform.  Doing so could have accelerated the forward momentum of value-quality-cost-based reforms beyond the 2016 elections.

2. That being said, health care providers need to increase their familiarity with the opportunities as well as perils of payment reform as well as the very real barriers to fixed payment schemes.

3. The announcements are a reminder how CMS is still fixated on the EHR, while the real innovation is occurring in handhelds and their associated applications.  The PHB figures that its not about the providers and their desktop electronic records, but about patients and their smart phones. As these devices continue to grow in speed, power and sophistication, providers who figure out how to use the iPlatform to leverage self-care, communication and decision support will thrive.....

With or without Medicare's incentives, promotion or IT policies.

Image from Wikipedia
Leaderboard